《中小学数学》(初中版)分别在2008年第1—2期和2009年第4期以及2009年第10期刊登了马俊芳老师的《对一道中考概率题的质疑》、赵才老师的《“质疑”是否多虑了》、刘龙庆老师的《真的“多虑了”吗?》三篇文章,三位老师分别从不同的角度对2007年江苏省扬州市中考数学试卷第23题提出了各自不同的看法和 “Primary and secondary mathematics” (junior high school version) in 2008, 1-2 and 2009, No. 4 and 2009, No. 10 published Ma Junfang's “questioning the probability of a midterm test”, Zhao Cai's “ ”Three questions, “ question ”is more worrying “, Liu Longqing teacher ”really “ thought for ”three? Articles, the three teachers from different angles on 2007 Yangzhou City, Jiangsu Province, mathematics exam papers 23 questions put forward their own different views and