《中国古籍整理研究论文索引》,作为一部工具书,是令人失望的。据本书凡例,《索引》所收论文取自由清末至一九八三年间一千五百余种报刊杂志,但不附引用报刊目录。八十年间,海内外各种报刊叠相交错,重名与改名现象屡见不鲜。只注刊名,而不作任何说明,不免令检索者茫然。且刊名亦忽此忽彼,并不统一。如第298页并列 “Chinese ancient books collation research index”, as a reference book, is disappointing. According to the legend of this book, the articles collected in the “Index” are collected from over 1,500 newspapers and periodicals published in the late Qing dynasty and in 1983 but not quoted in the catalog of newspapers and periodicals. During the past 80 years, various newspapers and magazines at home and abroad have been staggered in overlapping and overlapping forms. Common names and names are not uncommon. Only annotations, without any explanation, can not help but make the searcher dazed. The title also suddenly and suddenly, not uniform. As the same page 298