我非常欢迎祝勇先生的反批评。见仁见智,各说各话,学术才会活跃、发展。我尤其主张指名道姓、针锋相对的驳诘问难,认为这样可以培养人们的学术勇气和学术责任感。蔡元培先生“兼容并包”的精神对今天的教育、文艺、学术都至关重要。蔡先生的“兼容并包”中,就是含着各抒己见和相互批评。北大教 I very much welcome Mr. Zhu Yong’s anti-criticism. Different opinion, each talking, academics will be active and development. In particular, I hold the view that it is hard to argue against the names of surnames and tit-for-tat, arguing that this can help cultivate people’s academic courage and academic responsibility. Mr Tsai Yuan-pei’s spirit of “inclusiveness and compatibility” is of crucial importance to education, literature and art, and academia today. Mr. Choi’s “compatible package”, is containing various expressions of opinion and mutual criticism. Beijing University