在我的心目中,李陀、郝大铮同志是被看作电影评论界的“先锋派”的。尽管我不赞同他们的某些观点、某些看法,却钦佩他们的先锋精神一敢于提出问题,敢于向人们已经习惯的所谓正确观念、正确观点挑战,敢于提出新看法的精神。一乱一治。不打破既有的规范、秩序,就不能前进,就不能在新的更高的水平上建立新的规范,新的秩序。先锋精神之可贵即在于此。然而,理论、科学毕竟是理论、科学。要更新旧观念、旧观点,首先要看准目标,切中要害;其次要拿出有理有据的新见解、新看法来,以一以贯之的逻辑力量服人。如果缺少这些,单靠先锋精神和变革的愿望,虽也可 In my mind, Li Tuo and Comrade Hao Dazheng are regarded as “avant-garde” of the film critic community. Although I disagree with some or some of their views, I admire their vanguard spirit of daring to ask questions, dare to give the correct concept of what people are accustomed to, correct views and challenges, and daring to come up with new ideas. A mess of governance. Without breaking existing norms and orders, we can not move forward and we can not establish new norms and new orders at a new, higher level. Pioneer spirit is valuable in this. However, theory and science are theoretical and scientific after all. To update old concepts and old ideas, we must first look at the target and focus our attention on it. Secondly, we must come up with new and valid opinions and new ideas and serve them with a consistent logic. If these are lacking, the vanguard and the desire for change can be relied on alone