孙静同志在1993年第2期《中国学校体育》“教学门诊”中问:罚违纪学生跑圈、做俯卧撑,既可以维护课堂纪律的严肃性,又可以增强学生体质,这有什么不对?这个问题提得好。过去,不少体育教师对变相体罚学生不仅不认为有什么不对,反而将其当作“严格要求”的经验来加以宣传推广,流毒很深,影响很坏。所以必须弄清这个问题,才能消除后患。那么,变相体罚学生到底错在哪里呢? Comrade Sun Jing asked in the Teaching Out-patient of “Chinese School Physical Education” in 1993: “It is wrong to punish students for running the ring and do push-ups to maintain the seriousness of classroom discipline and enhance students’ physique. This question is good. In the past, many physical education teachers not only did not think there was anything wrong with disguised corporal punishment students, but rather promoted it as a ”strict requirement" experience. The drug was deeply poisoned and the impact was very bad. So we must understand this problem in order to eliminate future troubles. So, in disguise corporal punishment students in the end where wrong?