《叔向贺贫》选自《国语》,近年来又被选为中学语文教材(初中语文第六册选用此文)。《叔》文通过人物对话的方式,围绕“宣子忧贫,叔向贺之”进行论述,列举栾、卻两家事例,并通过类比,得出结论,告诉人们“富则失德受殃,贫则建德扬名”的道理。笔者认为《叔》文的逻辑论证值得商榷。 “Tear to Hell” is selected from “Mandarin”, and in recent years has been selected as a middle school language teaching materials (junior high school sixth language use this article). Through the way of character dialogues, “Uncle Wen” discussed the issue of “procrastinating the public to worry about the poor and uncle from the common people”, enumerating Luan and two examples and using analogy to draw conclusions and telling people that “the rich are the victims of immorality and the poor Jiande famous ”truth. The author thinks that the logic argument of “uncle” is worth discussing.