“编辑学者化”这一提法本身并没错,正如现代作家、编辑孙犁先生所说:“编辑必须有学问,有阅历,有见解,有独到之处,应该成为学者或作家.”作为一名编辑,特别是做一名学术期刊的编辑,其自身必须具备一定的学术功底,有进行科研的能力.可问题是我们在讨论这一问题时,不能不切实际.根据“学者化”的口号,有人提出,“对自己所负责编辑的某一学科或主要学科,如文学、历史、哲学等要具有比较完全系统的把握,有相当深入的研究”.“学报编辑的学术水平 The term “editing scholarship” is not wrong in itself, as the editor-in-chief Sun Li said: “Editors must be knowledgeable, experienced, insightful and unique, and should be scholars or writers.” As a Editors, especially those who are editors of an academic journal, must have certain academic credentials and the ability to carry out scientific research themselves. But the problem is that we can not be impractical when discussing this issue. According to the “scholarly” Slogan, it was suggested that “there is quite a thorough study on a certain subject or major subject that it is in charge of editing, such as literature, history, philosophy, etc.”