论文部分内容阅读
北京市海淀区人民法院初审、北京市第一中级人民法院终审的恒升集团诉王洪等侵权案是我国法院审理的第一起网上商业诽谤案件。两审法院对案件事实的查证、判决结果和相关的司法文书都反映了较高的司法水平。然而,现行法律将对法人的诽谤与对自然人的诽谤等量齐观的做法既不利于对自然人人格尊严的保护,也不利于对企业信用、商誉和经济利益的保护。王洪等对恒升集团的诽谤属于侵害商誉和信用的商业诽谤行为,也是恶意滥用权利的行为。在网络空间同样需要遵循相应的法律、法规,不得滥用权利侵害他人的民事权益。网络空间的法治文明建设不仅需要立法和司法者的努力,也需要公众改变陋习,遵循法律和善良风俗。
The trial of Beijing Haidian District People's Court, the first Intermediate People's Court of Beijing Hengsheng Group v. Wang Hong and other infringement cases were the first cases of online commercial defamation in our courts. The verification of the facts of the case, the judgment of the court of second instance and the relevant judicial documents all reflect a relatively high level of judicial standards. However, the existing law, which treats the defamation of legal persons as the same as the slander of natural persons, is not conducive to the protection of the human dignity of natural persons or the protection of the credit, goodwill and economic interests of enterprises. The defamation of Hengsheng Group by Wang Hong, etc. is a commercial libel that infringes goodwill and credit, and is a malicious abusive act. In the cyberspace, the same laws and regulations should be followed as well, and the rights and interests of others should not be abused. The construction of the rule of law in cyberspace not only requires the efforts of legislators and judicial officials, but also requires the public to change bad habits and follow the law and good customs.