《近代史研究》2008年第3期刊登了彭剑博士《清季预备立宪九年清单并未宣布开国会年限》一文,该文诚如其标题所示,旗帜鲜明地向一百年来习以为常的传统观点提出挑战。文章对颁布九年清单诏书中含糊其辞的地方作了仔细分析,对清朝最高统治者宣布开国会年限时的心理状态予以充分 “Modern History Research” 2008 the third issue of Dr. Peng Jian, “the Qing dynasty preparatory constitutional nine years list did not announce the opening of a year,” a text, as the title shows, the clear-cut one hundred years accustomed to the tradition Point out challenges. The article gives a careful analysis of the vague places promulgated in the nine-year list edict and fully sums up the psychological status of the highest rulers of the Qing dynasty when the proclamation meeting was opened