讨论编辑学者化,首先要问,什么是学者?依笔者所见,学者应当是对某一专门学科有相当造诣的人,即在该学科做出独特贡献的人。大学毕业生不能称之为学者,因为他仅是接受了既成的知识,而没有在其所学的学科领域创造出属于自己的成果。编辑是否属于学者,首先要看编辑这个专业是否称得上是一个学科,然后看其是否在编辑学科中 Discussion editor scholar, we must first ask what is a scholar? In the author’s view, scholars should be quite accomplished person in a particular subject, that is, make a unique contribution to the subject. College graduates can not be called academics because they only accept the established knowledge and do not create their own achievements in the fields of science they study. Editing is a scholar, we must first look at the editorial profession is called a subject, and then see whether it is in the editing discipline