中国人民大学教授、中国秦汉史学会会长、博士生导师王子今我讲几点意见:一、进行这样的研讨,会议的形式非常好。我们开过很多种的学术研讨会,这种范围小一些的,主题比较集中的,切入点比较合理的,与会者有共同兴趣也有一定研究基础的会开得质量比较高。二、刘九生教授的学术路径、思路以及他的研究范式,我的理解,他的学术研究的特点是有强烈的探 Professor of Renmin University of China, President of China Qin and Han History Society, and a tutor of doctoral candidates Now I will make some comments: First, to conduct such discussions, the form of the meeting is very good. We have held many kinds of academic seminars. This kind of small and medium-sized topics with comparatively reasonable starting points and relatively common interests of participants also have a certain quality of research. Second, Professor Liu Jiu-sheng's academic path, ideas and his research paradigm, I understand that his academic research is characterized by a strong probe