高校具有较强的自治属性,显著区别于一般行政机关。司法审查如何平衡高校自治与保护学生合法权益的关系备受社会瞩目。虽然北大捍卫学术尊严值得称道,但这一案件却表明,维护程序正义比惩治抄袭者更重要。事件回顾近日,北大女博士于艳茹起诉母校北京大学案由北京市第一中级人民法院作出终审判决,法院认定北京大学作出的撤销于艳茹博士学位决定程序违法,亦缺乏明确法律依据,撤销之前北大作出的撤销学位的决定,同时驳回了于艳茹要求恢复其博士学位证 Colleges and universities have strong autonomy attributes that are significantly different from those of the general administration. How judicial review balances the autonomy of colleges and protects the legitimate rights and interests of students attracts the attention of the society. Although it is commendable to defend the academic dignity of Peking University, this case shows that it is more important to uphold procedural justice than to punish plagiarism. Event Review Recently, the doctoral program on the trial of Yuliu Medical College in Peking University was conducted by Beijing University Women’s Armed Forces Peking University. The court found Peking University’s decision to revoke its decision on the course of the Juris Doctor’s degree is unlawful and lacks clear legal basis. Before the revocation Peking University made a decision to rescind the degree, at the same time rejected the request to restore his doctoral degree