编辑同志:2006年,张老伯和老伴董大妈因感情不和分居。当时,张老伯和董大妈未对共同财产协商分割。2011年,张老伯的妹妹结婚,张老伯未与董大妈协商,将其返聘分的技术改造奖金四万元作为贺礼送其妹妹。董大妈得知后即提出异议,要求小姑返还。遭到拒绝后,董大妈向法院起诉,要求撤销张老伯的赠与。法院经审理判决张老伯的赠与财产无效。请问法院的判决对吗?读者胡林胡林读者:我国《婚姻法》第十七条规定:“夫妻在婚姻关系存 Editor’s Comrade: In 2006, Chang and his wife Dong aunt separated by feelings of discord. At that time, Zhang old man and Dong aunt did not split the joint property negotiations. In 2011, Zhang old man’s sister got married, Zhang old man did not consult with Dong aunt, will be returned to his part of the technological transformation bonus 40,000 as a gift to his sister. Dong aunt learned that immediately objected, asked her to return. After being denied, Aunt Dong sued the court and demanded the revocation of Chang’s gift. After the court ruled that Zhang old man’s gift property is invalid. Readers Hu Lin Hu Lin Reader: China’s ”Marriage Law“ Article XVII provides: ”The couple in the marriage relationship deposit