高培权先生发表于《语文学习》2006年第10期上的《“教教材”与“用教材教”辨析》(以下简称《辨析》)一文,批评“用教材教”这个理念“缺乏科学性,谈不上先进性,实在难以操作,只能使人难识语文教学的本真,陷入表面的虚浮”。钱林波先生发表于《语文教学通讯》(高中刊)2007年第5期上的《“教教材”与“用教材教”之再辨析》(以下简称《再辨析》),对此提出了自己的见解。应该说高、林二先生 Mr. Gao Peiquan was published in “Language Study” 2006 10th issue of “” teaching materials “ analysis (hereinafter referred to as ”Differentiation“) article, criticized ”teaching with “ this The concept of ”lack of science and advanced nature is difficult to operate and can only make it difficult to understand the true nature of Chinese teaching and fall into the surface of emptiness.“ Mr. Qian Linbo was published in ”Re-discussion on Teaching Materials“ and ”Useful Teaching Materials“ in the ”Language Teaching Newsletter“ (High School News) Issue 5, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as ”Re-analysis"). This raised his own opinion. It should be said that Mr. Gao and Mr. Lin