“碎片化”是否已成为历史研究的一个问题,这恐怕需要具体的实证说明。比如,这个问题在中国是由谁提出的?谁在提倡碎片化?谁在反对碎片化?各要达到怎样的效果?什么样的研究是碎片化?在近年的研究成果中大致占据怎样的比例?别的不说,《近代史研究》中有没有,分量如何?这些都是非常有意思的问题。 Whether the “fragmentation” has become a question of historical research may require concrete empirical evidence. For example, who proposed this issue in China, who advocates fragmentation, who opposes fragmentation, what are the effects? What kind of research is fragmented and what proportion of research results in recent years? In other words, is there anything in the “Study of Modern History” and what is the weight? These are all very interesting questions.