一、基本案情 1994年6月中旬,“新疆伊犁酿酒总厂”向工商部门提起申诉:新疆石河子一四二团新安酒厂生产的“新安”牌新安老窖(中度250克)的包装及商标标识与其“伊力”牌伊力老窖(中度250克)非常相似。调查结果,正如新疆伊犁酿酒总厂所述。 二、意见分歧: 一种意见认为:新安酒厂的这种做法不属于不正当竞争行为中的混淆行为,不能适用《反不正当竞争法》。 其理由:(1)“新安”牌新安老窖在使用包装及商 First, the basic case In mid-June 1994, “Xinjiang Yili Brewery,” filed a complaint to the business sector: Xin’an Liquor Group, 142 Shihezi Xin’an winery production Xin’an old cellar (moderate 250 grams) packaging and The logo is very similar to its “Yi Li” brand Yi Li Laojiao (medium 250 grams). Survey results, as described in Xinjiang Yili Brewery. Second, differences of opinion: One opinion that: Xin’an Winery this practice is not confused acts of unfair competition, can not apply “Anti-Unfair Competition Law.” The reason: (1) “Xin’an” brand new old cellar in the use of packaging and business