《电影艺术》八一年第一期发表了叶楠针对电影《巴山夜雨》引起的争论所写的《杂感》,作者对一些问题阐明了自己的观点。有人说,剧本不符合生活真实,是虚假的。作者指出,近来对文学作品的指责,莫过于“生活是这样子吗?”这已成为某些人的法宝了,是口头禅。我说,生活不是这个样子!在某种意义上说,如果一个作品和生活完全逼真,没有艺术赋于的思想、感情、神韵,它是失败的作品。其实,这样指责的人,多半并不是谈真实性问题,而是对某些作品的调子,感到不是惯常那样,看作是异端,而又有难言之隐,只好说“生活 The first issue of “Movie Art” published the “miscellaneous feelings” written by Ye Nan in the controversy over the movie “The Nightmare in the Mountains”. The author clarified his point of view on some issues. Some people say that the script does not meet the real life, is false. The author points out that the recent criticism of literary works is that “life is like this?” It has become a magic weapon for some people, and is a mantra. I said, life is not like this! In a sense, if a work and life are completely realistic, there is no artistic conception, emotion, charm, it is a failure of the work. In fact, most people who criticize this issue are not talking about the issue of authenticity. Instead, they are talking about the tone of some works and feel that they are not used to it. They regard it as heresy and have unspeakable implication. They have to say "living