西路军失败原因综论（上）──兼驳“有意让西路军失败”论董汉河关于西路军失败的原因，我已写过几篇文章，其他的有关著作中，有的也涉及到这一问题。孤立地看，所论多数都有道理。然而，当我们将所论的诸种原因放到一起思考时，便难免产生某些困惑和疑问：西路军失败的... On the Causes of the Failure of the West Route Army (I) - Refuting the “Intentionally Letting the West Route Army Fail” on Dong Hanhe’s Reasons for the Failure of the West Route Army, I have written several articles and some of the other related works are also involved To this question. In isolation, most of the arguments make sense. However, when we think about the various reasons we are putting together, some puzzles and doubts inevitably arise: the failed West Route Army ...