论苑近年来，宏观职能鉴定论成为档案鉴定研究领域倍受关注的一颗新星，大有引领长期裹足不前的档案鉴定理论突出重围之势。但笔者对此论尚有几点疑问，特在此文中提出，以求教于方家。一、宏观职能鉴定论是早期“职能鉴定论”的翻版，并未从根本上超越前者。早在上世纪二、三 In recent years, the appraisal of macroscopic functions has become a rising star attracting much attention in the field of archival appraisal, and the appraisal theory of archives, which led to long-term hesitation, has highlighted the trend of encirclement. However, I still have a few questions on this theory, especially in this article proposed to learn from Fang Fang. First, the appraisal of macroscopic functions is a replica of the early “appraisal of functions” and has not fundamentally surpassed the former. As early as the last two or three