关松林同志的《试论日本近代教育改革成功之动因》一文(载《日本研究》1990年第1期),对日本近代的教育体制作了较为详尽的分析,认为“从明治维新起……随着教育改革的完成,日本的教育实现了向资本主义教育的转变。取得了前所未有的成功”,“成为日本教育史上的里程碑。”这一点似乎已成定论。对此,愿与关松林同志做些商榷。 In his article “Motivation for the Success of Modern Educational Reform in Japan” (published in “The Japanese Studies”, No. 1, 1990), Comrade Guan Songlin made a more detailed analysis of the modern educational system in Japan and held that “since the Meiji Reform With the completion of the education reform, Japan’s education has achieved the transformation to capitalist education and achieved unprecedented success, ”“ becoming a milestone in the history of Japanese education. ”This seems to have come to a conclusion. In this regard, willing to discuss with the comrade Guan Songlin.