《语文学刊》88年3期发表了张红宾同志《“质疑”之质疑》一文(下称张文),此文是针对同刊87年2期柴万江同志《高中语文第三册几处注释的质疑》一文(下称柴文) 对“罢夫赢老易子而咬其骨”句的解释而发的。我认为柴、张二同志对比句的解释均有不妥之处,值得商榷。 “Chinese Journal” 88 three issues of Comrade Zhang Hongbin “” questioned “one article (hereinafter referred to as Zhang Wen), this article is for the same period 87 years 2 Chai Wan Jiang” high school language book three notes Questioned “a text (hereinafter referred to as Chai Wen) to” get rid of the old Yi Yi and bite the bone, "the sentence made the explanation. I think Chai, Comrade Zhang Er comparison of the explanations are not appropriate, is debatable.