关于对宋末元初人陈元靓所辑《事林广记·乐星图谱》的初步研究,我已发表了两篇论文;最近,陈应时同志著文,就有关问题与我商榷。鉴于《图谱》中的“犯调歌诀”自清代乾隆以来,虽经吴颖芳、潘怀素、丘琼荪、杨荫浏诸先生各作译解研究或评述,但疑点仍然很多,因此,我们这场讨论使十分必要了.要探讨这些歌诀,必须依靠《图谱》本 I have already published two essays on the preliminary study on the “Map of Things in the Light of Guang Lin and the Music Star” edited by Chen Yuanliang in the early days of the Song Dynasty. Recently, Comrade Chen Yingshi wrote a text and discussed with me on the relevant issues. In view of the fact that since the Qianlong song of the Qing Dynasty in the “Atlas”, since the Qing Emperor Qianlong of the Qing Dynasty, Wu Ying-fang, Pan Huai-sheng, Qiu Qiong-sun, and Yang Yin-liu have done research or comment on each of them, there are still many doubts. Therefore, Very necessary .To explore these verses, we must rely on the “map” of this