Comparison of Artificial Neural Networks, Geographically Weighted Regression and Cokriging Methods f

来源 :Chinese Geographical Science | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:wdtt111
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Soil macronutrients(i.e. nitrogen(N), phosphorus(P), and potassium(K)) are important soils components and knowing the spatial distribution of these parameters are necessary at precision agriculture. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of different methods such as artificial neural networks(ANN) and two geostatistical methods(geographically weighted regression(GWR) and cokriging(CK)) to estimate N, P and K contents. For this purpose, soil samples were taken from topsoil(0–30 cm) at 106 points and analyzed for their chemical and physical parameters. These data were divided into calibration(n = 84) and validation(n = 22). Chemical and physical variables including clay, p H and organic carbon(OC) were used as auxiliary soil variables to estimate the N, P and K contents. Results showed that the ANN model(with coefficient of determination R~2 = 0.922 and root mean square error RMSE = 0.0079%) was more accurate compared to the CK model(with R~2 = 0.612 and RMSE = 0.0094%), and the GWR model(with R~2 = 0.872 and RMSE = 0.0089%) to estimate the N variable. The ANN model estimated the P with the RMSE of 3.630 ppm, which was respectively 28.93% and 20.00% less than the RMSE of 4.680 ppm and 4.357 ppm from the CK and GWR models. The estimated K by CK, GWR and ANN models have the RMSE of 76.794 ppm, 75.790 ppm and 52.484 ppm. Results indicated that the performance of the CK model for estimation of macro nutrients(N, P and K) was slightly lower than the GWR model. Also, the accuracy of the ANN model was higher than CK and GWR models, which proved to be more effective and reliable methods for estimating macro nutrients. The important of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of different methods such as artificial neural networks (ANN) and two geostatistical methods (geographically weighted regression (GWR) and cokriging (CK)) to estimate N, P and K contents. For this purpose, soil samples were taken from topsoil (0-30 cm Chemical and physical variables including clay, p H and organic carbon (OC) were used as Results showed that the ANN model (with coefficient of determination R ~ 2 = 0.922 and root mean square error RMSE = 0.0079%) was more accurate compared to the CK model (with R ~ 2 = 0.612 and RMSE = 0.009 The ANN model estimates the P with the RMSE of 3.630 ppm, which were respectively 28.93% and 20.00% less than 4%, and the GWR model with R ~ 2 = 0.872 and RMSE = 0.0089% the RMSE of 4.680 ppm and 4.357 ppm from the CK and GWR models. The estimated K by CK, GWR and ANN models have the RMSE of 76.794 ppm, 75.790 ppm and 52.484 ppm. Results indicated that the performance of the CK model for estimation of Also, the accuracy of the ANN model was higher than CK and GWR models, which proved to be more effective and reliable methods for estimating macro nutrients.
其他文献
格林-巴利综合征即急性特发性感染性多神经根炎病变(AIP),其发病率为每年每百万人口中占1~1.5,这一数字在世界各国无多大差别。因此,本病并非常见,然而是周围神经病变的较严
本文对130例幕上脑梗塞病人的临床和CT进行对比研究,发现脑梗塞经CT证实动态发病为43%,静志发病为57%。脑梗塞在发病3~7天内CT检查阳性率最高。 In this paper, 130 cases of s
近年来社会医学作为医学模式转变中不可缺少的一门学科,而越来越受到人们的重视。社会医学是具有典型意义的交叉科学。它不仅是医学与社会学的交叉,而且是医学与经济学、法
六、脑动脉硬化【诊断标准】 1.年龄在45岁以上。 2.初发高级神经活动不稳定的症状及/或脑弥漫性损害症状。如头晕、失眠、头痛、健忘、智能下降、行为改变等。 3.有全身性
目的:分析急性危重症哮喘发病特点和规律,便于正确判断和处理病情。方法:对39例危重型哮喘患者住院观察,门诊随访,问卷调查,电话询问以及病史整理,并与同期39例重型哮喘患者
正多边形是指各边相等,各角也相等的多边形.文[1]提出“圆内接n边形内角相等,它是否一定为正n边形?”和“圆外切n边形各边相等,它是否一定是正n边形?”两个有趣的几何问题.  容易证明当n为奇数时,结论是肯定的.但n为偶数时,结论是不一定,存在非正n边形.  文[1]指出对一般的偶数n≥6给出反例是有意义的工作.  笔者经过一番研讨构造出了这样的非正n边形.
Alzheimer 氏病(AD)除有皮层胆碱能缺乏而外,纹状体多巴胺水平也可降低,这意味着同时有锥体外系功能障碍。本文作者对 AD 的锥体外系体征作了系统的研究。 Alzheimer’s di
好发于长骨干骺端的骨巨细胞瘤较常见,但颅骨巨细胞瘤则十分罕见。1983年我们收治2例,均经X线照片,手术及病理证实,现报导如下: 病例1,男,36岁,工人,住院号177001,患者左耳
请下载后查看,本文暂不支持在线获取查看简介。 Please download and view, this article does not support online access to view profile.
目前的研究表明,趋化因子在微血管肺损伤的发展过程中起着重要的作用,用差示逆转录酶多聚酶链反应发现一种鼠的类人α-趋化因子IP-10类似物,即mob-1。在鼠ARDS肺中,mob-1表