在哲学中有进步吗?“还有半杯”的观点是:在哲学中是有些进步的;“就剩半杯”的观点是:这种进步并没有我们认为的那么大。我将论述“就剩半杯”论的一个版本,并且提出一个关于如何解释它的关键问题。 Is there any progress in philosophy? “There is still half a cup.” The point of view is that there has been some progress in philosophy; the view that “the remaining half a cup is left” is that such progress is not as big as we think. I will discuss a version of the “left half-cup” theory and come up with a key question on how to interpret it.