天地会“西鲁传说”探幽曾五岳［编者按］天地会起源问题，是谜象环叠、聚讼纷争的世纪公案。而洪门秘籍“西鲁传说”，更是谜中谜，案中案，历代史家对其评价不一，褒贬都有。主要有洪门缘起的“信史说”、部分真实说和荒诞不经毫无史料价值说。本文作者从方法论等角度提... Heaven and earth will “Xilu legend” to explore Once upon a time [Editor’s note] Heaven and Earth will be the origin of the problem, is the mystery ring stack, dispute litigation century act. The door cheats, “Xiru legend” is the mystery mystery, the case of the case, historians of different ages on its evaluation, praise and devaluation have. Mainly originated from the “door of history”, part of the truth and absurd without historical value without saying. The author of this article from the perspective of methodology ...