日前，笔者拜读了郝铁川教授在《法商研究》 1998年第 4期上刊登的《论现代法本质的另一面》 (以下简称《本质》 )一文，读后有不同感想，特就该文的观点提出商榷。 　　《本质》一文引用了下列事实来论证法律的制定和运行都只能体现少数人的意志： 1立法者与选民的意志常常 Recently, I read a book entitled “On the Other Side of the Essence of Modern Law” (hereinafter referred to as “Essence”) published by Professor Hao Tiechuan in the fourth issue of “Commercial Research” 1998, Discuss point of view. The article “Essence” cites the following facts to prove that the formulation and operation of laws can only reflect the will of the minority: 1. The will of legislators and voters often