《法律科学》98年1期登载了裴苍龄同志的《论证据资料》一文（以下简称《裴文》），其独特的论证角度令人耳目一新。但对其中一些观点，也有商榷之处。一、关于“模糊了勘验、检查和鉴定的性质，也模糊了勘验、检查人和鉴定人的性质”问题《裴文》认为：“勘验、检查笔录是由勘 “Legal Science” 98, 1 issue of Comrade Pei ’s “evidence of argument” (hereinafter referred to as “Pei Wen”), the unique perspective of argument is refreshing. However, some of these views are also open to question. First, on the “blurred the nature of the inspection, inspection and appraisal, but also blurred the nature of the inspection, inspector and appraiser” “Pei Wen” that: "The inspection, inspection transcripts by the survey