辨证》认为陈振孙著录的《东坡别集》是苏峤所刊建安家集,而赵希弁著录的《东坡先生别集》、《续别集》则是《东坡别集》的补遗。实际上二人所著录的应是一书,只是赵氏所录为其初版,陈氏著录乃其合编增补版,所收为苏峤刊刻建安家集时删削的篇目。没有证据表明建安家集为分类合编本,但《东坡别集》作为其删略文字的结集,则应是采用了分类合编的体例。 Dialectics “that Chen Zhen-sun’s” Dongpo Dianjiu “is a collection of books written by Su-jian and” Dongpo “written by Zhao Xi-chi, while” Farewell set “is the addendum of” Dongpo-dijiu “ . In fact, the two men should record a book, only Zhao recorded as its first edition, and Chen’s writings are its compilation of supplements, which are collected when the Su-jian carved Jian-an episode deleted articles. There is no evidence that Jian’an Family Collection is a classified compilation, but the collection of ”Dongpo Collection" should be a combination of classification and compilation.