论文部分内容阅读
Three More Pilots
In mid-December， 2014， after long and intense debate， China finally announced the winners that will be the next free trade zone pilots： Guangdong Province， Tianjin City and Fujian Province. The Shanghai Free Trade Zone model is catching on in China.
Port city of Tianjin， 120 kilometres southeast of Beijing， is， as it were， the capital’s maritime gateway to the world. The Tianjin Free Trade Zone is to include the Dingjian Bonded Port Zone， the Tianjin Bonded Port Zone and the Central Business District in the eastern part of Binhai New Area.
Guangdong Province in South China is the neighboring province of Hong Kong and Macao. The Guangdong Free Trade Zone is in future to extend to Shenzhen， Zhuhai and Guangzhou and is also to include connecting routes to Hong Kong and Macao.
Fujian Province in Southeast China is north of Guangdong and opposite Taiwan. The Free Trade Zone is to be di-vided into the areas of Xiamen （shipping centre）， QuanzhouMeizhou （feeder port）， Pingtan Iceland （headquarters， services and housing） and Fuzhou （manufacturing industry/high-tech）.
According to a statement posted on the State Council’s website earlier， the government will expand financial and trade trials that started in Shanghai’s free trade zone.
The Shanghai FTZ started in September， 2013 as a testing ground for freeing interest rates and boosting the yuan’s role in global transactions. The zone has customs areas where goods stored are exempt from tariffs and value-added taxes. However， many investors have been disappointed by the progress made in the zone and say it provides almost no advantages for foreign or domestic companies operating there. The State Council also promised more experimentation would be conducted within the existing Shanghai FTZ to encourage foreign investment and the development of advanced manufacturing and the service sectors.
The new zones will be based on the Shanghai model but will also include “local characteristics”， the statement said.
The Government is also hoping the zones will push manufacturers into upgrading from the low-end manufacturing that made China an export powerhouse over the last two decades.
Growth in Chinese trade has been lackluster for the last year and has slumped in recent months， causing concern among policy makers who are also confronted with a sharp slowdown in domestic real estate and serious overcapacity throughout the industrial sector. Negative Lists
As an experimental project， the Shanghai FTZ has been under close scrutiny since its launch. Among the pilots tried in the zone， the adoption of a “negative list” – a list of areas closed to foreign investment – has won applause because in theory it opens more areas to foreign investment and reduces government intervention in business activity.
However， a gap has opened between the original design and policy implementation. The Guangdong official said businesses found difficulties to enter some newer industries not on the negative list – such as those related to the Internet – because local officials had limited experience in handling these businesses.
For instance， the Shanghai FTZ allows foreign investors to set up wholly owned health care institutions， but Shan Xiaohu， a partner at the consulting firm Strategy&， said medical practices run by foreign doctors still need the approval of central government agencies and are limited to one year of operations. “The authorization doesn’t belong to the FTZ on this issue，” he said.
Companies in the Shanghai FTZ want the city’s government to take advantage of support from think tanks and other resources to improve its governance capacity and professionalism， especially when drafting specific industry standards and guidelines， Shan said.
Foreign firms also want the negative list to shrink and to enjoy greater openness， he said.
In June， the Shanghai FTZ slashed the number of items on the list from 190 to 139， but critics said it is still too long. The State Council meeting urged the zone’s leaders to make more cuts， and further open the services and advanced manufacturing sectors.
The new FTZs will follow the example of Shanghai and adopt the negative list approach， Feng said.
More Financial Reform Pilots
The most watched aspect of the Shanghai FTZ is financial sector reforms， such as liberalization of the capital account and interest rates， and cross-border settlement of the yuan. Since the zone opened， financial regulators have approved 51 measures regarding financial reforms.
One of the most applauded moves was the launch of a free-trade account that allows for greater flexibility in crossborder yuan flows. Money transfers between the accounts and those between the accounts and offshore or non-resident accounts – opened with a bank in China by overseas entities and individuals – are not subject to the restrictions on crossborder fund flows. By the end of last October， 10 Chinese commercial banks joined the pilot and around 7000 accounts had been opened. Many experts say the steps taken by the Shanghai FTZ have fallen short of expectations. Some measures implemented in the Shanghai FTZ have brought on little changes， a senior executive of a financial company in Guangdong said.
Cheng Bo， the secretary general of the Free Trade Zone Research Center at Shanghai University of Finance and Economics， said companies must meet many requirements to be part of the experimental reforms. Most of the qualified companies have operated in the bonded area for many years and have little demand for capital. Meanwhile， new entrants with greater demand for funding fail to meet the requirements.
“The Shanghai FTZ has tackled some issues （in financial reform）， but not the fundamental ones，” Cheng said. The FTZ should assess its measures and work closer with central government agencies to further deepen and expand the reforms.
Zhang Xin， deputy director of the central bank’s branch in Shanghai， said at a ceremony marking the anniversary of the FTZ’s opening that the capital account liberalization pilot would serve as a test for nationwide reform. The free-trade account program will be a starting point for the overall liberalization of the capital account.
However， a source close to the Guangdong’s commercial department said the experiment to push capital account liberalization in Shanghai will not be expanded soon.
Ji， from PricewaterhouseCoopers， said it would take a lot time to improve the regulation and the free-trade account system， and assess the performance of reforms. In addition， time was needed to work out sufficient supervision before measures could be expanded.
The Shanghai FTZ is also backed by Beijing’s ambition to develop the city into an international financial hub， and Ji said this means the zone will continue to serve as the testing ground for overall and systemic reforms of the financial sector.
In mid-December， 2014， after long and intense debate， China finally announced the winners that will be the next free trade zone pilots： Guangdong Province， Tianjin City and Fujian Province. The Shanghai Free Trade Zone model is catching on in China.
Port city of Tianjin， 120 kilometres southeast of Beijing， is， as it were， the capital’s maritime gateway to the world. The Tianjin Free Trade Zone is to include the Dingjian Bonded Port Zone， the Tianjin Bonded Port Zone and the Central Business District in the eastern part of Binhai New Area.
Guangdong Province in South China is the neighboring province of Hong Kong and Macao. The Guangdong Free Trade Zone is in future to extend to Shenzhen， Zhuhai and Guangzhou and is also to include connecting routes to Hong Kong and Macao.
Fujian Province in Southeast China is north of Guangdong and opposite Taiwan. The Free Trade Zone is to be di-vided into the areas of Xiamen （shipping centre）， QuanzhouMeizhou （feeder port）， Pingtan Iceland （headquarters， services and housing） and Fuzhou （manufacturing industry/high-tech）.
According to a statement posted on the State Council’s website earlier， the government will expand financial and trade trials that started in Shanghai’s free trade zone.
The Shanghai FTZ started in September， 2013 as a testing ground for freeing interest rates and boosting the yuan’s role in global transactions. The zone has customs areas where goods stored are exempt from tariffs and value-added taxes. However， many investors have been disappointed by the progress made in the zone and say it provides almost no advantages for foreign or domestic companies operating there. The State Council also promised more experimentation would be conducted within the existing Shanghai FTZ to encourage foreign investment and the development of advanced manufacturing and the service sectors.
The new zones will be based on the Shanghai model but will also include “local characteristics”， the statement said.
The Government is also hoping the zones will push manufacturers into upgrading from the low-end manufacturing that made China an export powerhouse over the last two decades.
Growth in Chinese trade has been lackluster for the last year and has slumped in recent months， causing concern among policy makers who are also confronted with a sharp slowdown in domestic real estate and serious overcapacity throughout the industrial sector. Negative Lists
As an experimental project， the Shanghai FTZ has been under close scrutiny since its launch. Among the pilots tried in the zone， the adoption of a “negative list” – a list of areas closed to foreign investment – has won applause because in theory it opens more areas to foreign investment and reduces government intervention in business activity.
However， a gap has opened between the original design and policy implementation. The Guangdong official said businesses found difficulties to enter some newer industries not on the negative list – such as those related to the Internet – because local officials had limited experience in handling these businesses.
For instance， the Shanghai FTZ allows foreign investors to set up wholly owned health care institutions， but Shan Xiaohu， a partner at the consulting firm Strategy&， said medical practices run by foreign doctors still need the approval of central government agencies and are limited to one year of operations. “The authorization doesn’t belong to the FTZ on this issue，” he said.
Companies in the Shanghai FTZ want the city’s government to take advantage of support from think tanks and other resources to improve its governance capacity and professionalism， especially when drafting specific industry standards and guidelines， Shan said.
Foreign firms also want the negative list to shrink and to enjoy greater openness， he said.
In June， the Shanghai FTZ slashed the number of items on the list from 190 to 139， but critics said it is still too long. The State Council meeting urged the zone’s leaders to make more cuts， and further open the services and advanced manufacturing sectors.
The new FTZs will follow the example of Shanghai and adopt the negative list approach， Feng said.
More Financial Reform Pilots
The most watched aspect of the Shanghai FTZ is financial sector reforms， such as liberalization of the capital account and interest rates， and cross-border settlement of the yuan. Since the zone opened， financial regulators have approved 51 measures regarding financial reforms.
One of the most applauded moves was the launch of a free-trade account that allows for greater flexibility in crossborder yuan flows. Money transfers between the accounts and those between the accounts and offshore or non-resident accounts – opened with a bank in China by overseas entities and individuals – are not subject to the restrictions on crossborder fund flows. By the end of last October， 10 Chinese commercial banks joined the pilot and around 7000 accounts had been opened. Many experts say the steps taken by the Shanghai FTZ have fallen short of expectations. Some measures implemented in the Shanghai FTZ have brought on little changes， a senior executive of a financial company in Guangdong said.
Cheng Bo， the secretary general of the Free Trade Zone Research Center at Shanghai University of Finance and Economics， said companies must meet many requirements to be part of the experimental reforms. Most of the qualified companies have operated in the bonded area for many years and have little demand for capital. Meanwhile， new entrants with greater demand for funding fail to meet the requirements.
“The Shanghai FTZ has tackled some issues （in financial reform）， but not the fundamental ones，” Cheng said. The FTZ should assess its measures and work closer with central government agencies to further deepen and expand the reforms.
Zhang Xin， deputy director of the central bank’s branch in Shanghai， said at a ceremony marking the anniversary of the FTZ’s opening that the capital account liberalization pilot would serve as a test for nationwide reform. The free-trade account program will be a starting point for the overall liberalization of the capital account.
However， a source close to the Guangdong’s commercial department said the experiment to push capital account liberalization in Shanghai will not be expanded soon.
Ji， from PricewaterhouseCoopers， said it would take a lot time to improve the regulation and the free-trade account system， and assess the performance of reforms. In addition， time was needed to work out sufficient supervision before measures could be expanded.
The Shanghai FTZ is also backed by Beijing’s ambition to develop the city into an international financial hub， and Ji said this means the zone will continue to serve as the testing ground for overall and systemic reforms of the financial sector.