本刊 ２０００年１１期《监察顾问》刊登《这种行为是否违纪违法？》后，各地读者纷纷来信参与讨论，围绕文中提出的来自检察机关、一审法院、二审法院和企业纪检监察部门的几种定性意见，谈了各自的看法。对这一案例读者意见比较统一，认为张某等人的行为已经违法违纪，应受到 Publication 2000 11 issue of “supervision consultant” published "This behavior is illegal or illegal? After the readers all over the world sent letters to participate in the discussion, they discussed their own views on the several qualitative opinions raised by the procuratorial organs, courts of first instance, courts of second instance and the discipline inspection and supervision departments of the enterprises. The views of readers in this case more uniform, that Zhang’s behavior has been violated the law, should be