Accidentally True Beliefs and the Williamsonian Mental State of Knowing

来源 :中国哲学前沿 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:milan_27
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
In this paper,I will explore some philosophical implications of Williamson's thesis that knowing is a state of mind(KSM).Using the fake barn case,I will introduce a way to evaluate Williamson's KSM thesis and determine whether the Williamsonian mental state of knowing can be plausibly distinguished from certain other similar but epistemologically distinctive states of mind(i.e.,accidentally true beliefs).Then,some tentative externalist accounts of the supposed differences between the Williamsonian mental state of knowing and accidentally true beliefs will be critically assessed,implying that the evaluated traditional versions of externalism in semantics and epistemology do not fit well with Williamson's KSM thesis.Ultimately,I suggest that the extended-mind or extended-knower approach may be more promising,which indicates that active externalism would be called for by Williamson's KSM thesis.
其他文献
土地革命战争时期,无数红军战士为了民族独立与人民解放舍生忘死,创造了史诗般的英雄业绩,铸就了永恒的历史丰碑,镌刻了彪炳史册的红色记忆.下面特选五则红军在宁都感人肺腑
期刊
1976年12月,黄华任中华人民共和国外交部部长,在党中央的领导下全面主持外交部工作,中美关系正常化(以下简称“正常化”)便是在其任内完成的.但其实早在1971年7月,黄华就曾任
期刊
随着我国老龄化程度加深和疾病谱发生变化,大病照护成为中国社会面临的重大挑战.作为对家庭照护和专业照护力量的补充,护工日渐成为医疗机构中为重病患者提供照护的主要群体.这一方面缓解了医院护理劳动力不足的困境,另一方面又因照护质量参差不齐引发社会担忧.基于在G市三所医院开展的田野调查,本文在微观互动、社会网络和社会结构三个层面探讨情感劳动发生的社会条件,并提出一种以"关系"为核心的情感劳动分类方式.其中,"消极情感劳动"以维持现有情感连接状态为主要目标,以管控负面情绪为主要手段;"积极情感劳动"以促进情感连接为
《民法典》是我国重要的法律,随着《民法典》的正式实施,如何才能准确应用《民法典》中的相关条款,这成为法律工作者必须要认真思考的问题.《民法典》是当前规范我国民事行为
Ming-Huei Lee 李明煇 is a leading philosopher and intellectual historian in Taiwan,China,and is highly-regarded throughout the wider Chinese cultural region.Lee
期刊
Upon reading the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus,readers might be confused about the nature of the book,since there seems to be a paradox introduced by the autho
In his timely book Inoue Enryō:A Philosophical Portrait,Rainer Schulzer offers a detailed study of the life and works of Inoue Enryō(1858-1919),a philosopher
期刊
新时期环境下,人工智能已经融入人们生活的各个方面,在人工智能的广泛应用下,引发了一系列现实的法律问题.人工智能的出现打破了原有民事法律对主体、客体地位的界定规则,让
In“Wittgenstein and Qualia,”Ned Block presents an inversion argument for qualia.Taking Wittgenstein's notes as the starting point,Block argues that if we admi
In this paper we investigate the implications of recent scientific discoveries in animal perception on the philosophical views regarding epistemic entitlement.W