论文部分内容阅读
本文梳理了四要件体系下不纯正不作为犯罪成立认定的评价顺序、三阶层体系下的不纯正不作为犯罪成立认定的评价顺序,并在此基础上对母亲女友案系列案进行了尝试性的认定评价。案例适用过程显示,四要件体系的评价顺序在简单案例适用中具有较简便的特性,但是,因其犯罪构成体系自身的原因,无法体系思考犯罪排除事由。三阶层体系的评价顺序在复杂案件的评价上更具有优势。
This article combs the order of appraising the establishment of impure omission as a crime under the four-component system and the order of affirming appraisal of impure innocence under the three-tier system. On the basis of this, I try tentatively on the series of cases of mother girlfriend Identify the evaluation. The case application process shows that the evaluation sequence of the four-component system has simpler features in the application of simple cases. However, due to its own causes, it is impossible to systematically consider the causes of criminal exclusion. The evaluation sequence of the three-tier system is more advantageous in the evaluation of complex cases.