《林则徐年谱新编》是一部非常富有学术与文献价值的著作,颇得学术界的好评。但细读全书,仍发现些许问题与史实不符,如魏源是道光二十四年进士,林昌彝为林则徐的同乡后辈,以及孙毓是林则徐的同年友等,均不能成立。考察相关史料,魏源是道光二十五年进士,林昌彝为林则徐的族弟,孙毓与林则徐根本不是同年友。这些问题尽管是白璧微瑕,但也有辨析的必要。 Lin Zexu New Year’s Book is a very rich academic and literature value of the book, rather academic critics. However, reading the book still found some problems inconsistent with the historical facts. For example, Wei Yuan was a tutor of Daoguang for twenty-four years, Lin Changyi was a fellow worker of Lin Zexu, and Sun Yu was the same friend of Lin Zexu at the same year. Investigate the relevant historical data, Wei Yuan is the twenty-five years of Daoguang Jinshi, Lin Changyi Lin Zexu’s brother, Sun Yu and Lin Zexu is not the same year friends. Although these problems are very bleak, they are also necessary for discrimination.