TOWARDS A GLOBAL UNDERSTANDING OF THE HUMANE TREATMENT OF CAPTURED ENEMY FIGHTERS

来源 :ARTICLES | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:luxi0194
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
The prevailing narrative instructs us that humane treatment of captured enemy fighters is down to white knights from the western parts of the European continent with their codes of chivalry,or alternatively,the Swiss businessman Henri Dunant.This contribution challenges that narrative for overlooking,or being ignorant of,the way that societies around the world have approached the matter of the captured enemy fighter.Traces of some of the critical principles about humane treatment that we see in our present law can actually be found in much older societies from outside of Europe.A more accurate and representative way of understanding humanitarianism in the treatment of captured enemy fighters can and must be crafted,with the prevailing Euro-centric account balanced with practices,cultures and faiths from elsewhere.The quest to achieve more humane treatment in armed conflict is first and foremost a battle of the intellect.Narratives and conceptualisations that are more inclusive,recognising and appreciating of the ways of the rest of the world are likely to be more effective in communicating humanitarian ideals.This work adopts a new method of approaching the richness and diversity of the treatment of captured enemy fighters over time and space.This new framework of analysis uses six cross-cutting themes to facilitate a broader international and comparative perspective,and develop a more sophisticated level of understanding.The first theme is how older and indigenous societies approached the matter of captured enemy fighters.The second focuses on religions of the world,and what they teach or require.The third section examines the matter of martial practices and codes of ethics for combatants in certain societies.The fourth category engages with colonisation and decolonisation,and regulation (or non-regulation) of the treatment of captives of war.Fifth is the issue of modernisation and the impact it has had on armed forces and fighters,including on the treatment of captives.The final issue is the shift towards formalised agreements,beginning with the first bilateral agreements and then the multilateral codification exercise that began in the mid-19th century and continues to this day.This framework for analysis leads into a final chapter,presenting a fresh and holistic view on the evolution of prisoner of war protections in the international order.It provides a different way of looking at Intemational Humanitarian Law,starting with this effort at a global understanding of the treatment of captured enemy fighters.
其他文献
从2012年第四季度亏损8990万美元,到2013年第一季度盈利1125万美元;从四年前向官方申请贷款资助4.6亿美元,到日前提前9年一次性清偿所有负债,显现在美国特斯拉公司(Tesla)身
电波传来日军投降的讯息    抗日战争时期,我在广东志锐中学毕业后,到广西柳州业勤小学当教师。这所学校和志锐中学一样,是由国民党第四战区司令长官张发奎创办的,他亲自担任学校董事长。但是,该校校长和一些教师都是中共秘密党员,是第四战区司令部的一个中共秘密组织——中共特别支部的成员。这个秘密党组织直接受中共长江局(1939年后改为南方局)和周恩来的领导,担负着在张发奎指挥的国民党军队中,宣传贯彻党的全
In China,different factors can influence the judicial decision-making process of the courts.However,in more than 30 years' development,the courts appear to rely
期刊
“九一三”事件发生后,为了不打草惊蛇,1971年国庆节后,中央决定让邱会作(前排右三)出访越南。10月底,邱会作在人民大会堂被捕。 After the “September 13 Incident”, in
摘 要:商事仲裁中能否裁决由败诉方承担胜诉方的律师费,在理论和实践中争议较大。许多国际仲裁机构及国内较大仲裁机构均在本机构仲裁规则中规定:仲裁庭有权根据当事人的请求,裁决由败诉方承担胜诉方因办理案件支出的合理律师费。但仍有许多机构未作规定。在实践中,许多有经验的律师都会在仲裁请求中提出由对方当事人承担其律师费。然而,因不同仲裁机构对此问题的看法不同,最后的处理结果也不尽相同。因此,有必要探讨商事仲
我们讲改善民生,文化应该是一个很重要的组成部分;我们讲公平公正,文化应该是一个不可或缺的重要体现;我们讲幸福指数,文化应该是一个很重要的衡量尺度;我们讲生活 We say i
摘要:品牌代表着企业精神与文化,是企业技术创新的符号载体,但由于经营不善、创新不足、保护不力等原因,致使众多企业品牌名存实亡,创新主体为增进品牌的持续价值,必须通过创新手段与方法进行社会实践活动,基于“奥斯本法则”的技术创新活动就使得企业品牌在市场竞争中具备了优势竞争力。  关键词:品牌;技术创新;奥斯本法则  品牌创新主体应时刻保持创新的意识与行动,基于“奥斯本法则”中的六个发问:可以改变吗?可
期刊
期刊
举步维艰的“脱欧”进展增加了外国投资者对英国市场未来前景不确定性的担忧,如果英国最后“硬脱欧”,那么它将面临欧盟对其与第三国地位相同的待遇。一旦欧盟法对英国失效,英国商品将无法自由进入欧盟市场,意味着从英国出口至欧盟的商品需要交纳关税。“脱欧”正在让英国失去吸引力,许多投资者考虑将企业迁移到欧盟其他国家,德国成热门之选。与此同时,投资以德国为代表的欧盟市场面临的管控日趋严格。德国豪金律师事务所律师
期刊