《错误的价值判定应该被纠正》一文提出“弱化档案鉴定”理念,以纠正错位的价值判定,保证档案的完整性。然而,该文在价值鉴定的“用词”“边界”“主体”等方面认识模糊;论证“弱化鉴定”的前提也不周延,论证视角从鉴定的质向量转换出现偏差;信息技术增强及资金投入等应对也存在缺陷。因而“弱化档案鉴定”的提出,并不是档案鉴定理论的升华,而如今信息社会档案鉴定更必不可少。 “Wrong value judgments should be corrected,” a paper put forward the idea of ​​“weakening file appraisal” to correct the wrong value judgment and ensure the integrity of the file. However, the article is vague in aspects such as “” “” “subject ” of value identification, and the premise of argument “weakening identification There is deviation; information technology and capital investment and other response also flawed. Therefore, ”the weakening of file identification" is not the sublimation of the theory of file authentication, and now the identification of information society is more essential.